Attic conversion or granny flat – which is best for you?
Whether you purchased your home as a renovation project or to serve as your forever home, your house is an investment. And, in the times of Airbnb and student housing, renovating your property for a rental return is becoming increasingly popular.
What used to be a way to take care of ageing parents has turned into a potential investment opportunity. Converting an attic into a habitable space or building a granny flat are two home renovations which increase property value, rentable space, and overall investment. However, both projects involve a great deal of effort and time not to mention a hefty sum of money. So, is converting an attic or erecting a granny flat in the backyard worth the hassle? Will it really add value and make you money?
The Specifics Accessory Dwelling Unit is the official term used by architects and city planners, but is synonymous with granny flats, in-law suites, backyard cottages, she sheds, etc. These units include a kitchen, bathroom, and living space as well as their own entrance. These units can take a few structural forms—the most common being:
- Stand-alone unit
- Garage conversion/over the garage build
- Attic or basement conversion
- Sectioning off part of the existing house
Depending on where you live, restrictions and regulations on these units will vary – each jurisdiction will likely have its own ordinance passed, outlining the rules for these units. Local and state ordinances will include regulations on things like:
- Maximum unit size
- Lot coverage
- Where it can be rented as a short-term rental
- Whether owner occupancy is required
And there may be even specific regulations regarding renovation details like head heights, windows, and ventilation.
Granny flats would be considered a standalone unit and tend to be a fan-favorite among homeowners with excess space on their property. While you could fill this space with additional landscaping or play area for the kids, building a self-contained housing unit means extra livable space for children, ageing parents, or potential rental income from tenants.
For those who don’t have extra property space to renovate on, building up instead of out may be an option. Attic conversions, while also a type of accessory dwelling unit, are built inside the main property, utilising unused roof space.
Making it happen
Unlike building additions and completing renovations in the main space of a home, completing an attic conversion or granny pod is relatively unobtrusive because clients can remain in their homes while the units are being built. But just because you’ve decided to make the addition doesn’t mean you can just jump right in.
There’s a little red tape to clear before starting your build. The first thing you should do is check with the local council to be sure that building a granny flat or rental conversion will be permitted on your block or property. Councils in different regions have various requirements for residents wanting to build or renovate on their block of land. For example, in some areas of Queensland, it’s only permissible to rent out a granny flat if a family member will be living in it, and in some areas, housing density restrictions prohibit them entirely. Be sure to check with your local council before putting any down payments in place or signing any building contracts.
The next step is to consider the financial aspects of building your granny flat or attic conversion. You can get in touch with local builders and specialists to get an estimate for your project. Granny pods will be more costly, because it’s a complete addition while attic conversions tend to be less expensive as they aren’t a freestanding building.
It’s important to ensure your finances are in place from day one if you plan to embark on any kind of renovation project. Either type of addition won’t cost as much as building a home, so you may be able to finance it by accessing your equity or by increasing or refinancing your current loan. Alternatively, you may be able to take out a construction loan. Contacting a banker or financial consultant will be beneficial if this is a new process to you— they’ll be able to determine how much you can afford to spend and help get your budget in order
The pros and cons of attic conversions v granny flats
Someone could construct a granny flat in the yard or convert their attic space for a multitude of reasons. You could revamp the attic space so it becomes extra liveable square footage for your family (think a bedroom or an additional recreation room), or you could put up an ageing parent while still granting them access to the main house. Likewise, you could construct a granny flat without amenities like a kitchen, because the inhabitant may have access to the main house – or the space may be used by you.
However, one of the main reasons for people constructing additional living space on their land is to maximize the property’s equity or to create a way to make passive income (renting it out to tenants).
The process for obtaining permits and making the decision to build granny flats or converting attic space is similar, but there are pros and cons of each to consider before committing to your project.
Cost and requirements
Both granny flats and attic conversions require obtaining permits from your local council that adhere to council and building codes – think attributes like windows, headspace, minimum (or maximum) square footage, rooflines, etc. – and will vary depending on your region. Also, both projects will require a fairly large investment; however, attic conversions tend to be less expensive.
If renting the space, a granny flat is ideal. Because it’s a free-standing structure, it will have its own entry access, kitchen, bathroom, and common spaces. However, you will have to determine and consider how much access to the main property the tenants will have. Do you want to be having a summer BBQ in the yard while the tenants are hanging by the pool? Probably not.
Unlike building your rental out, building up (attic conversion) is a desirable option but may come with less privacy. You could easily build out a self-sustaining unit (bathroom, kitchen, and living space) in an attic conversion, so you will retain some privacy from the main house. However, attic spaces generally don’t have their own point of entrance – meaning your tenants will likely have to enter through the entrance of the main home. If the whole property is comprised on rentals, you may be able to work out a hallway or shared entrance situation, but if you and your family are living in the main house, you will want to consider this.
Something a lot of people don’t immediately consider when adding additional living space is parking for their new tenants. If you live on a corner lot and build a granny flat, not only will it have its own entrance but it’s likely the tenant’s parking spaces will be on another street than your own. However, if you are renting attic space, you should make sure you have taken parking into account. Lack of parking (or inclusion of it) will make an impact of potential rental value.
Is it worth the investment?
Like we said earlier, the addition may or may not be worth the investment – depending on your situation and intention.
Adding either a granny flat or attic conversion space could add 20-30% to the value of your property, not to mention the potential income from rentals.
However, when it comes to resale, that’s when the value of the investment gets tricky. If you have added a granny flat or converted your attic to rentable space and make the decision to sell your property later, the value of that conversion will depend on the future buyer.
For example, if you have a buyer interested in your property who is also interested in renting out space for passive income, great! You’ve just found someone who will consider your investment worth it. On the other hand, if your new buyer is intending the property to be a single-family property, they may not be too keen on a second kitchen in the attic or the fact there’s an apartment in the backyard. Just because the investment was worth it to you, doesn’t mean they care to pay for it…because they wouldn’t have made the investment in the first place.
Adding a granny flat or converting the attic to liveable space could potentially be a great investment for your property. It could increase the overall home value or be a way to generate additional income. However, there are things to consider before committing – things like cost, value of investment, and any rules and regulations that should be abided by. It’s smart to consult with building professionals, your local council, and potentially real estate agents to determine if the investment would in fact add value to your property and to make sure you are legally allowed to make the build.
Buy smarter = limitless ways to build lifetime income
Crave Property Advisory is a unique property strategy and buyers agent service. As the only independent and unbiased advisory that can help you use any property strategy Australia-wide, Crave’s services extend to home, investment and commercial property. A highly client focused organization, Crave developed the Modular Investing System (MI System) to provide clients with the ability to use a tailored mix of strategies and efficiently build profitable portfolios that create lifetime income.
Debra Beck-Mewing is the CEO of Crave Property Advisory, and has more than 20 years’ experience in property investing, Australia-wide. She has used a range of strategies to build her property portfolio including renovating, granny flats, sub-division and development. Debra is skilled in identifying development opportunities, and sourcing properties that have multiple uses and multiple exit strategies. She is a Qualified Property Investment Advisor, licensed real estate agent and also holds a Bachelor of Commerce and Master of Business.
Disclaimer – This information is of a general nature only and does not constitute professional advice. We strongly recommend you seek your own professional advice in relation to your particular circumstances.
Trackback from your site.